Gate QA re-presentation · CHECK001 continue · HDO act pending

T104-PH001-AC005-GATE001Package-shaped gate

The recycled package is ready for a fresh gate decision

The approved General Proposal authoring baseline remains one self-contained canonical HTML file, an operational Markdown fallback, and an honestly deprecated dual-file route. After the first GATE001 presentation was recycled, the same PR absorbed Contract Amendment 01, an upstream-authority variance record, bounded cycle-03 remediation, a fresh 26-criterion review, exact-candidate browser closure, and an internal-delta CHECK001 re-entry. The remaining decision is the HDO’s new disposition on that amended package.

Gate package: PR #545 · returned to draft for recycle; ready at re-presentation
Amended contract: #326 · criteria 1–23 as amended + 24–26
CHECK001: continue · 25/26 + C-001 closed
Recommended gate act: accept-and-close

Authority boundary · this view approves nothing

This QA page is a non-authoritative working instrument. Its checkboxes, selection controls, copied note, staging URL, and visual state are not a gate disposition and are never stored.

The durable act is a new, explicit HDO instruction or comment on PR #545. The 2026-07-22 recycle act remains historical and is not overwritten. Only a new approving disposition authorizes merge; the later #325 acceptance ledger binds the merge hash and terminal closeout.

Journey to GATE001

Every cycle and assurance boundary remains visible

Two linked trails are shown without rewriting history. The first is the package baseline that reached the original gate. The second begins with the durable recycle act and supplies the amended proof for this re-presentation.

Package baseline before recycle

0
CHECK000
Commissioned route
Merged
PR #493 · 7882ac52 · 1A/2A/3A/4A/5A-interim.
1
TK001 cycle 1
Build + review
Recycle
4 Situation-A defects; all bounded.
2
TK001 cycle 2
Remediate + review
23 / 23 · superseded
Immutable unconditional PASS under the original basis; superseded by amendment, never erased.
A
Main Consultant
Integrity audit
Clean
Lineage, hashes, topology, and mechanics reproduced.
×
External attempt
Plan boundary
blocked_access
No merits verdict and no contamination.
O
HDO replacement
External Opus
23 / 23 baseline
Authorized package-baseline review; ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS, zero package-merits defects.
C
Consultant closure
G-1–G-3 closed
Continue
Governance-record repairs only; G-4 advisory.
G
First GATE001
Adversarial QA
Recycle
Confirmed instruction-hygiene and upstream-authority defects; prior baseline retained.

Recycle arc · 2026-07-22

R
GATE001 act
Recycle recorded
PR #545
Durable comment 5042290969; same PR returned to draft, unmerged.
A
#326
Amendment 01
26 criteria
Criteria 11, 13, 16 amended; criteria 24–26 added.
V
Master PRD #98
Variance recorded
Inspectable
Comment 5042309431 records the GD1=5A-interim authority chain.
3
Cycle 03 Developer
Bounded remediation
2ef4a413
Guideline 354→176 lines; bytes −40.3%; class scan clean.
Q
Fresh Reviewer
De-novo merits
25 / 26
ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS; only C-001 browser evidence remained.
C
Direct Consultant
C-001 closed
Exact candidate
Playwright at 375/768/1280; bytes, controls, privacy, and network passed.
✓
CHECK001 re-entry
Internal delta mode
Continue
HDO-authorized mode; 2026-07-17 external review remains baseline, not rerun.
H
Now · GATE001
Re-presentation
Pending
PR marked ready; HDO retains all four dispositions.

Superseded by citation Pre-recycle conclusion: cycle 02’s 23/23 PASS and the HDO-authorized external replacement remain immutable package-baseline records. They do not prove the later amended criteria and are not presented as the current gate basis.

Current conclusion: candidate 2ef4a413 received a fresh Reviewer verdict of ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS at 25/26. The only condition, C-001, was closed against the exact canonical HTML hash through the three-viewport Playwright matrix. The Main Consultant then recorded CHECK001 continue in the HDO-authorized internal-delta mode.

Assurance continuity across recycle

The external baseline stands; cycle 03 adds a fresh internal review and exact-candidate closure

The first external session still did not reach merits. Its HDO-authorized replacement remains the full-package baseline from 2026-07-17. Contract Amendment 01 expressly replaced the external-review sentence for this re-entry only, so cycle 03 used a fresh de-novo internal Reviewer plus a direct-Consultant browser closure. No event is relabelled or erased.

Original target-scoped attemptblocked_access

Session d528b825-84c6-4ec9-87ad-1b1b2952a19c. No merits finding; worktree and request remained clean. Read the preserved non-merits record.

HDO-authorized replacement baselineBaseline retained

Session a72405cd-a63f-47bb-8c07-2ef2a7a31663. Original-basis 23/23; G-1–G-3 directly closed, G-4 advisory. Read the replacement disposition.

Fresh cycle-03 Reviewer25/26 + condition

Candidate 2ef4a413. ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS; zero material defect; C-001 was evidence-only. Read the fresh REVIEW.

Direct-Consultant C-001 closureClosed

Exact candidate and SHA-256 served byte-identically; 375/768/1280 matrix passed with zero unexpected console, overflow, persistence, cookie, or network result. Read the closure.

Plain-language boundary

What this package changes—and what it leaves alone

Accepting and merging does

Make one self-contained HTML file the canonical construction for new General Proposals.
Keep one-file Markdown as the supported fallback and deprecate the older dual-file construction for new authoring.
Encode independent architecture and governance decision lanes, richer labelled internal detail, and Analysis as the sole semantic feed.
Land a reusable template that preserves the accepted visual and interaction carrier while making execution IDs conditional and the displayed reference construction-agnostic.
Adopt placement and naming mechanics from P-STD-004/P-STD-005 by reference and state the master-PRD-as-varied authority posture honestly.
Authorize merge of the exact re-presented PR package; AC005 closes only after merge and the merge-hash-bound #325 ledger.

Intentionally does not

Activate the reserved proposal_level=detail altitude or reopen CHECK000 decisions.
Delete or rewrite historical dual-file proposals, the accepted control, frozen Analysis, prior cycle/review records, or standards.
Rewrite the master PRD #98 body, complete durable PRD/standard reconciliation, or execute the proposal-family formalization track.
Create a second PR, separate Markdown GDPP, or default independent GATE001 Reviewer.
Approve, merge, close, or move any board item merely because this page is checked, copied, staged, or the PR is marked ready.

HDO confirmation matrix

Twenty-seven checks cover the amended 26-criterion basis and the upstream-authority recurrence guard

Confirm a row only after opening its evidence anchors and following the disclosed target, exact command or path, and expected passing signal. Criteria 11, 13, and 16 are visibly amended; 24–26 are new. The final authority row is deliberately additional so the defect class that forced recycle remains visible at every future gate.

Working through the matrix0 / 27 confirmed

0 of 27 confirmed

A Authority, topology, and construction posture

Criteria 1–6 establish the execution authority, single carrier, and three-construction posture retained through recycle.

Criterion 01Original · PASS

I confirm the implementation remains bound to CHECK000 merge 7882ac52 and dispositions AD1–AD4 / GD1 = 1A/2A/3A/4A/5A-interim.

CHECK000 merge · 7882ac52 Sidecar provenance

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckPackage lineage and encoded decision provenance.

Exact command / path

rg -n '7882ac52|1A|2A|3A|4A|5A-interim' templates/consultant/workspace/changelog/changelog_guideline_workspace_proposal.md

Pass signalThe sidecar binds the CHECK000 merge and all five exact dispositions; cycle-03 evidence §4 row 1 is PASS.

Criterion 02Original · PASS

I confirm issue #326 remains the sole active child-task SSOT and no retired TK002–TK005/TK007 task was revived.

#326 · sole active task Cycle-03 EVIDENCE §2

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckActive acceptance manifest and retired-task boundary.

Exact command / path

sed -n '28,35p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/evidence/evidence_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03_2026-07-22.md

Pass signalThe manifest contains exactly TK001 / #326; no retired task appears as an active target.

Criterion 03Original · PASS

I confirm every repository and cycle artifact remains on the one registered package branch and PR #545; no second implementation, review, checkpoint, or gate PR exists.

PR #545 · sole package Delta assessment · findings 1–4

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckLinear chain and single-PR topology.

Exact command / path

sed -n '27,40p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/analysis/analysis_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03-delta-reentry-assessment.md

Pass signalThe chain is f3a6b245 → 2ef4a413 → 3efc6ae4 → b7c7255e, linear, on one branch and one PR.

Criterion 04Original · PASS

I confirm single_file_html is canonical for new General Proposals in the guideline and both templates.

Guideline · candidate Canonical HTML · candidate

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckCanonical-construction agreement.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'single_file_html' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalAll active authoring surfaces identify HTML as canonical; none identifies Markdown as canonical.

Criterion 05Original · PASS

I confirm single_file_md remains a usable, metadata-aligned fallback with an explicit fallback reason and the same authority boundary.

Markdown fallback · candidate Construction route

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckOperational fallback, not a nominal label.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'single_file_md|fallback_reason|non-authoritative|sole semantic feed' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal.md

Pass signalThe fallback reason, semantic feed, lanes/readiness, and HDO boundary are present and aligned.

Criterion 06Original · PASS

I confirm dual_file_html is deprecated once for new authoring while historical files and compatibility references remain intact.

Guideline · compatibility rule EVIDENCE · GAP-004

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckOne deprecation rule; no historical rewrite.

Exact command / pathrg -n 'dual_file_html' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md

Pass signalExactly one guideline match states deprecated-for-new-authoring compatibility; protected history is byte-unchanged.

B Content model, amended hygiene, and validation

Criteria 7–18 preserve the accepted model and expose every recycle-sensitive instruction, design, validation, and context obligation.

Criterion 07Original · PASS

I confirm reserved proposal_level=detail stays inactive while labelled internal Detail and rich media remain available beneath active proposal levels.

Guideline · altitude boundary HTML · labelled Detail

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckAltitude remains reserved; internal depth remains useful.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'proposal_level.*detail|reserved|internal Detail|rich media' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalDetail is described as inactive at proposal altitude and non-authoritative when used internally.

Criterion 08Original · PASS

I confirm a proposal carries independently dispositionable Architecture and Governance lanes for one coherent subject, with full AD depth and compact consequential/non-routine GD depth.

Guideline · lane rule Fallback · independent lanes

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckOne subject, two independent thresholds and dispositions.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'independent|consequential|non-routine|Architecture|Governance' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalThe lanes do not collapse; AD is full-depth and GD is compact and thresholded.

Criterion 09Original · PASS

I confirm Detail, Example, and Proposed carry-forward remain three distinct, labelled, non-authoritative content roles, including for rich media.

Guideline · content roles HTML · role labels

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckRole separation and non-authority.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'Detail|Example|Proposed carry-forward|non-authoritative' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalAll three labels appear with different functions; none acquires decision authority.

Criterion 10Original · PASS

I confirm a grounding Analysis is the sole semantic feed and both proposal constructions remain non-authoritative HDO disposition surfaces.

Guideline · semantic-feed rule HTML · visible authority boundary

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckSemantic input and decision-owner boundary.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'sole semantic feed|non-authoritative|HDO' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalAnalysis alone supplies semantics; proposal controls and payloads explicitly do not perform the HDO act.

Criterion 11Amended · PASS

I confirm reusable content names the normalization/pipeline owner only as the proposal-family formalization track—never as an issue number or execution UID—and uses only governed PENDING markers where necessary.

Amendment 01 · criterion 11 Remediated guideline

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckArtifact-class ownership wording only.

Exact command / pathrg -n 'proposal-family formalization track|AC007|#500' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md

Pass signalThe generic track wording is present; AC007 and #500 are absent from reusable body prose.

Criterion 12Original · PASS

I confirm the canonical HTML preserves the accepted visual/interaction carrier without creative redesign; cycle 03 changes only conditional/generalized metadata and displayed-reference substitutions.

Accepted visual control REVIEW §4.3 · hash proof

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckDesign and executable preservation.

Exact command / path

sed -n '150,166p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/review/review_T104-PH001-AC005_CHECK001_cycle-03_attempt-01.md

Pass signalCSS hash cd093a58… matches cycle 02; normalized script hash 24f6b67f… matches; no redesign is found.

Criterion 13Replaced · PASS

I confirm the amended class-based scan covers timeline UIDs, issue/PR literals and URLs, register IDs, and commit hashes across all three reusable deliverables, with only sidecar provenance and comment-form PENDING markers allowlisted.

Amendment 01 · criterion 13 EVIDENCE §7 · exact scan

Concrete HDO check · exact recorded command and passing signal

CheckAll forbidden identifier classes, not activity literals only.

Exact command / path

sed -n '117,146p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/evidence/evidence_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03_2026-07-22.md

then run the quoted five-part rg block unchanged.

Pass signalRaw stdout is zero bytes; a positive UID scan finds only the two valid comment-form PENDING markers.

Criterion 14Original · PASS

I confirm the canonical template preserves its restrictive CSP, keyboard/interaction and responsive structure, advisory payload, and zero-storage/zero-unintended-network posture.

Canonical HTML · exact candidate Independent static posture

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckSecurity, privacy, accessibility, and advisory behavior.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'Content-Security-Policy|localStorage|sessionStorage|document.cookie|fetch\(|XMLHttpRequest|WebSocket' templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal_single-file-html.html

Pass signalThe restrictive CSP is present; prohibited persistence/network APIs are absent; review §4.3 reports PASS.

Criterion 15C-001 closed · PASS

I confirm exact-candidate HTML validation and the full Playwright matrix passed at 375, 768, and 1280 after the Reviewer’s sole evidence-only condition C-001 was directly closed.

C-001 closure · exact candidate Candidate · 2ef4a413

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckCandidate/hash binding, viewports, controls, privacy, network, errors.

Exact command / path

sed -n '1,52p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/verification/verification_T104-PH001-AC005_CHECK001_cycle-03-c001-closure.md

Pass signalHTML SHA-256 8e275213…ac74 matches; 375/768/1280 have no overflow or console errors; storage/cookies empty; only loopback document requests occur; payload/copy pass.

Criterion 16Extended · PASS

I confirm the guideline was substantively reduced toward its peer class and no longer duplicates authority or historical handoff content: 354→176 lines, 20,015→11,951 bytes, estimated tokens 5,004→2,988.

EVIDENCE §8 · size budget 176-line guideline

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckExact line/byte reduction and deterministic token estimate.

Exact command / pathwc -l -c templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md; estimate = ceil(bytes / 4).

Pass signal176 11951; −178 lines (−50.3%), −8,064 bytes (−40.3%), and 2,988 estimated tokens (−40.3%).

Criterion 17Original · PASS

I confirm a fresh agent can identify the canonical, fallback, and deprecated routes; required inputs and roles; validation route; and authority boundary without historical session context.

Active guideline Fresh Reviewer judgment

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckInstruction sufficiency from active surfaces alone.

Exact command / pathsed -n '1,176p' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md then open the chosen active template.

Pass signalThe reader can select construction, source Analysis, apply roles/lanes, validate, and route authority without consulting cycle history.

Criterion 18Original · PASS

I confirm placeholders are subject-, count-, scope-, date-, and downstream-route-neutral, so phase-scoped proposals require no dummy execution IDs.

HTML · stable placeholders Markdown · conditional metadata

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckForward-compatible schema and repeatable decision blocks.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'PROPOSAL_REFERENCE|include when applicable|repeat|optional' templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalExecution IDs are conditional; references and decision blocks are generalized; no activity/issue/date/hash binding remains.

C Cycle protocol, protected scope, and amended authority

Criteria 19–26 cover immutable review mechanics, the three-cycle cap, protected identities, adopt-by-reference, the varied upstream authority, and conditional template IDs.

Criterion 19Original · PASS

I confirm every valid cycle has one immutable EVIDENCE artifact and one fresh Reviewer-owned REVIEW; cycle-01 and cycle-02 pairs remain byte-unchanged and cycle 03 adds, never appends to, its pair.

REVIEW §4.4 · immutable pairs

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckHistorical pair identity and cycle-03 separation.

Exact command / path

sed -n '168,188p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/review/review_T104-PH001-AC005_CHECK001_cycle-03_attempt-01.md

Pass signalFour historical SHA-256 values reproduce byte-unchanged; cycle-03 EVIDENCE and REVIEW are separate artifacts bound to 2ef4a413.

Criterion 20Original · PASS

I confirm the Reviewer prompt preserves Reviewer-owned classification/verdict, bounded-condition fields, material-defect recycle/reject routing, and the rule that non-merits outcomes do not pass.

Cycle-03 commissioning addendum Fresh verdict

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckBinding verdict-role contract.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'Reviewer-owned|ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS|non-merits|RECYCLE|REJECT' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/communication/internal/handoff_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_*

Pass signalAll required ownership and routing semantics are explicit; the fresh Reviewer applies them.

Criterion 21Original · PASS

I confirm cycle 03 is the third and final default-loop cycle and returned a passable merits verdict; no cycle 04 was created or authorized.

REVIEW · cycle-cap judgment

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckThree-cycle cap and escalation boundary.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'third and final|cycle 04|within the hard cap' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/evidence/evidence_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03_2026-07-22.md artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/review/review_T104-PH001-AC005_CHECK001_cycle-03_attempt-01.md

Pass signalCycle 03 is within cap and passable; any failed closure would escalate instead of creating cycle 04.

Criterion 22Original · PASS

I confirm frozen Analysis/proposal/standard identities, prior cycle pairs, plans, notes, owner surfaces, and unrelated files remain unchanged; the recycle delta is bounded and fully enumerated.

Delta assessment · scope proof

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckBounded delta and protected identities.

Exact command / path

sed -n '33,43p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/analysis/analysis_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03-delta-reentry-assessment.md

Pass signalThe final delta is exactly 10 files (4 deliverables + 6 governance/evidence); prior pairs are unchanged and protected hashes reproduce.

Criterion 23Original · PASS

I confirm the Developer returned the complete trace on open PR #545 without performing CHECK001, merge, issue/board closure, or GATE001 acts; the PR’s draft/ready changes are Consultant-owned lifecycle acts.

PR #545 · returned draft, then ready REVIEW row 23

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckRole-safe handback and one open PR.

Exact command / path

sed -n '222,244p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/review/review_T104-PH001-AC005_CHECK001_cycle-03_attempt-01.md

Pass signalCriterion 23 is PASS on available evidence; no Developer control-node act exists; #545 remains the sole unmerged carrier.

Criterion 24New · adopt-by-reference · PASS

I confirm placement, naming, and stream-compatibility obligations are adopted from P-STD-004/P-STD-005 by reference; the duplicated placement table, filename patterns, stream_id rule, and stream validation row are gone.

P-STD-004 P-STD-005

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckAuthority references present; local restatement absent.

Exact command / pathrg -n 'P-STD-004|P-STD-005|stream_id|placement table' templates/consultant/workspace/guideline_workspace_proposal.md

Pass signalOwning standards are cited directly; duplicate placement/stream rules do not appear.

Criterion 25New · upstream consistency · PASS

I confirm every deliverable claim about general_proposal agrees with master PRD #98 as varied by its recorded 2026-07-22 interim-construction variance; the guideline does not claim clean agreement with the unvaried body.

Master PRD #98 #98 variance record Dedicated recurrence guard ↓

Concrete HDO check · path and passing signal

CheckEight deliverable claims against the varied upstream authority.

Exact command / path

sed -n '94,108p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/evidence/evidence_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03_2026-07-22.md

Pass signalAll rows are CONSISTENT, CONSISTENT SUPPLEMENT, CONSISTENT WITH RECORDED VARIANCE, or CONSISTENT BOUNDARY; none silently overrides #98.

Criterion 26New · conditional IDs · PASS

I confirm activity_id, task_id, and checkpoint_id are conditional in both templates and the HTML title, displayed Reference, and payload use construction-agnostic PROPOSAL_REFERENCE.

HTML · generalized reference Markdown · conditional IDs

Concrete HDO check · command and passing signal

CheckConditional schema and phase-scoped usability.

Exact command / path

rg -n 'include when applicable|PROPOSAL_REFERENCE|CHECKPOINT_ID' templates/consultant/workspace/template_workspace_proposal_general-proposal*

Pass signalAll three execution IDs say include when applicable; CHECKPOINT_ID remains only optional metadata; every displayed/payload reference is generalized.

QA-UA-01Permanent upstream-authority guard#upstream-authority-qa

Beyond criterion 25, I independently confirm the deliverables agree with master PRD #98 as varied, and the variance’s authority chain is inspectable end to end: CHECK000 GD1=5A-interim → PR #493 merge 7882ac52 → P-STD-008-CLAUSE-002D altitude rule → P-STD-001-CLAUSE-011 variance routing → #98 comment 5042309431.

PR #493 merge · 7882ac52 Variance record · 5042309431 P-STD-008-CLAUSE-002D P-STD-001-CLAUSE-011

Independent authority-chain check · exact paths and passing signal

CheckBoth substantive agreement and inspectable authorization/routing—never “files unchanged” as a proxy.

Exact command / path

sed -n '94,108p' artifacts/tasks/T104/workspace/PH001/AC005/evidence/evidence_T104-PH001-AC005-CHECK001_cycle-03_2026-07-22.md

rg -n 'P-STD-008-CLAUSE-002D|P-STD-001-CLAUSE-011' artifacts/tasks/P/standard/standard_P-STD-008_workspace-development-lifecycle-standard.md artifacts/tasks/P/standard/standard_P-STD-001_program-governance-standard.md

Pass signalThe eight-claim comparison passes; 002D forbids silent lower-altitude override and routes variance; CLAUSE-011 defines explicit variance documentation; #98 records GD1/PR #493 and the three construction axes.

Owner-bound residue

The activity closes without consuming these routes

These are deliberate post-merge or owner-bound routes, not unresolved CHECK001 defects. The recycle findings are closed; no default GATE001 Reviewer is commissioned; and the amended basis is fully satisfied after C-001 closure.

Routed open

Proposal-family formalization · durable reconciliation

Owns broader normalization, service/pipeline mechanics, the master-PRD artifact/body reconciliation, design-specification formalization, and eventual PENDING-marker removal. The reusable deliverables name this owner only by artifact class.

Future subtype

AC009 / #502 · gate_disposition

Owns future gate-disposition subtype normalization. This GATE001 uses the approved package-shaped precedent and does not execute or rebody #502.

Routed input

Instruction-surface governance

The wider skills/templates/guidelines hygiene class remains routed input for its owner. AC005 now demonstrates class-based scanning and adopt-by-reference without claiming that owner scope.

No defect

CHECK001 · continue after recycle

Fresh cycle-03 REVIEW is ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS at 25/26; C-001 is directly closed; the amended 26-criterion basis is fully satisfied; internal-delta re-entry is clean.

By direction only

GATE001 Reviewer

No independent Reviewer exists by default. The HDO may explicitly direct one, but none is required or implied by this package.

Recorded-act semantics

Choose a working disposition, then record it on PR #545

These controls are view-only and advisory. Nothing is submitted, persisted, or sent. They unlock only after all 27 confirmations—including the permanent authority guard—are checked. The recommended outcome reflects the closed recycle proof; the HDO retains all four gate dispositions.

What approving means now: after PR #545 is marked ready for re-presentation, the HDO posts a new unambiguous GATE001 accept-and-close instruction on that PR. It accepts the exact amended package at the presented identity—including cycle-03 remediation and closed C-001—and authorizes that package’s merge.

What approving does not mean: it does not erase the 2026-07-22 recycle act, promote the superseded cycle-02 23/23 record into current proof, rewrite #98’s body, complete the formalization route, or turn checkboxes, staging, copied text, CHECK001 continue, PR ready state, or any advisory verdict into approval.

Merge horizon: new durable HDO act → authorized merge of the exact PR package → #325 acceptance ledger binding the merge hash, QA identity, and terminal activity closeout. Until the first step occurs, merge and terminal transitions remain unauthorized.

Incomplete: confirm all 27 claims and select a working disposition.

Optional rationale · state the blocker for recycle, hold, or kill

Provenance, construction, and self-conformance

This QA surface

Source head before this QA rebuild: 6ae5e4a5.
Recycle chain: f3a6b245 addendum → 2ef4a413 Developer candidate → 3efc6ae4 fresh REVIEW → b7c7255e C-001 closure → 6ae5e4a5 CHECK001 re-entry assessment.
Current package: PR #545; the same single package, returned to draft for the recycle span and marked ready when this re-presentation is assembled.
Decision reference: analysis_T104-PH001-AC005-GATE001_qa-disposition-synthesis.md v1.1.1.
Hosted identity: the new GATE001 publication evidence records this rebuilt source’s committed/served SHA-256, bytes, hosting identity, headers, and live browser proof after staging; this page does not self-attest its own future commit or hosted bytes.
Construction: one self-contained HTML document; no external assets, fonts, libraries, analytics, forms, storage, cookies, IndexedDB, fetch/XHR, or runtime calls.
Security/privacy: strict inline CSP; noindex,nofollow; all external links open with noopener noreferrer.

Package-shaped gate conformance and unchanged decision semantics

This surface implements the P-STD-008-CLAUSE-005G/H review grammar: the honest baseline plus recycle journey (§1), merge effects and exclusions (§2), 26 amended criteria plus the permanent upstream-authority guard (§3), owner-bound residue (§4), and re-presentation recorded-act semantics (§5). The HDO still records exactly one of accept-and-close, recycle, hold, or kill as a durable platform act. This surface remains advisory, non-authoritative, and non-persisting.